What is in a name?

Sun Jun 24 17:35:27 2012

Image of the Velociraptor

I have heard some discussion on the continued use of the velociraptor now that there is a PhP framework of the same name.

Personally I would be forced not to answer 'so what?'. I don't think it is important that there is a similar usage of the name and I don't think it matters that it is in a language some people see as a competitor to Perl 5.

The language isn't Perl and that is fairly obvious, so anyone confused are likely to not understand about Perl anyway; the framework are as free to use the word as we are and the relevance is simply that.

I am not sure why people are always striving towards this idea of 'unique' when it comes to naming conventions. Surely it is the marketing and branding that is important. If we use 'velociraptor' in association with Perl 5 more then the PhP framework does, if we get a historical dominance then we need not even concern ourselves from a marketing or promotional viewpoint.

I guess there is a fear of being identified with that project, or being contaminated by it. But, we suffer that anyway. Unless we make up fairly new words or portmanteau some traditional ones (Mojolicious anyone?), we are always going to run into this. Try Googling Catalyst without adding the word Framework for an example of what I mean.

-mdk

Digg! submit to reddit Delicious RSS Feed Readers


If anyone has feedback (and until we have a commenting system) please don't hesitate to email me at: m.keating [at] shadowcat.co.uk, if your comments are useful, fun, or just plain interest to me, or if I think will be useful to others, then I will add them to the end of this post, let me know how you would like to be named (anon, nick etc.).

Comments

Mark Keating is: Managing Director of Shadowcat Systems Limited
Director and Secretary of Enlightened Perl Organisation
Chair of the Marketing Committee for The Perl Foundation
Co-Founder/Co-Leader of North-West England Perl Mongers
Work Blog: Mark Keating on Shadowcat
LinkedIn Profile: Mark Keating on LinkedIn
Perlesque Blog: Mark Keating on per.ly
My Public Blog: Mark Keating's Personal site
Twitter Feed: Mark Keating on Twitter
Facebook: Mark Keating on Facebook
Flickr: Mark Keating on Flickr
Family site: Mark Keating's Family Site
Flavor.me Combined Feeds: Mark Keating on Flavor

Mark Keating is the organiser of the London Perl Workshop (since 2008), has joined the organising team for the QA Hackathon in 2011, the TPF GSoC Mentors/organisers 2011, the Dynamic Languages Conference 2011.